Sci-fi showdown and the REAL answer: Enterprise-D vs Pegasus (BSG-reimagined). Version 2.0.
https://www.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=122172200324839464&id=61575183947832 PEGASUS . Cain would get Picard to lower Shields as Pegasus approaches to physically dock with Enterprise for a “conference.“ Colonial theology would be used to refuse being beamed aboard. At the last possible second, Pegasus would ram Enterprise right in the neck. Then FTL jump out of there before the warp core goes.